You have to see this exchange at the FutureHitDNA blog.
Credibility is everything.
If you make a claim about making money in this business, you better be able to back it up - the unwashed masses love nothing more than a good takedown - a disrobing of fake emperors.
It may indeed be that Alex Day is The Next Big Thing (my professional opinion: no). But if he's making money as he claims, then it should be absolutely elementary to shut me down by opening up a spreadsheet and showing us how it's done.
The posts author, JayFrank, when prompted to highlight some details, writes:
How does someone who wants to be taken seriously walk away with a non-response such as this??
Why would anyone who takes themselves seriously read/trust this blog when they can't get basic details right?
Because this is all hype.
(PS: Look at the stats on his new video: See that near perf diagonal line? That means it's bullshit - "organic" traffic does not look like that. Logarithmic graphs mean Russian botnets. Sorry, Alex and Jay.)